Get to Know Us

Our story

When Covid-19 hit, like many others, I found myself at a crossroads. The world was changing, and with everything uncertain, I decided to take a leap of faith and pursue something I had always dreamed of—starting my own business. That’s when The Calla Lily Cookie was born, and it has been an incredible journey ever since.

The name of my business holds a very special meaning—Calla Lily is a blend of my two daughters’ names, Callie and Lily. They are my inspiration, my driving force, and the reason I pour so much love into every cookie I make. My passion lies in creating beautiful, delicious royal icing cookies that are as stunning as they are tasty. Every batch I bake is crafted with care, bringing joy and sweetness to those who experience them.

Starting my cookie business during such a challenging time wasn’t easy, but it gave me the opportunity to focus on something I love and turn it into a way to connect with others. I’ve been able to bring a little bit of happiness to people’s lives through my art, and for that, I am incredibly grateful.

NOT JUST ANOTHER COOKIE

At Calla Lilly Cookie, we take pride in being an integral part of the St. Joseph community, where our passion for baking shines through every cookie we create. With over 3,000 cookie cutters at our disposal, we’re dedicated to crafting unique and delicious treats that cater to any event or occasion. Our recent feature on WSBT news highlights our commitment to providing the best cookies, and we invite you to come and taste the love baked into every design. Let’s sweeten your celebrations together!

DON'T JUST TAKE IT FROM US

At Calla Lilly Cookie, we are passionate about baking beautifully crafted custom cookies that taste as good as they look. With more than 20 glowing five-star reviews and recognition in Edible Michiana magazine, our creations have gained a reputation for excellence in our local community. We believe that every occasion deserves a special treat, and we work diligently to ensure that your cookies are tailored to your vision, making each event truly memorable.

"Should have ordered a few extra cookies! I planned on eating 1/2 of the one extra we had so my husband could try them. Well my husband is going to miss out. I couldn't stop myself! These cookies are delicious. Highly recommend"

ANGELA C.

"I was introduced to these delicious creations at a recent graduation party. I am a home cake bakery and have sampled many decorated cookies in my life. These are literally the best I have ever eaten. Thick, soft, perfectly flavored and decorated with care and perfection."

PEGGY F.

"Angie goes above and beyond to deliver the the cutest cookies! I will find an excuse to order these. She does an amazing job! Can't wait to surprise our grandson with Grinch cookies. Thank you!"

AIMEE B.

"The cookies taste amazing and look picture perfect! Angie is A+ to work with as well as fast response. Highly recommend for any occasion!"